Three formulas, three answers
The first two work from height, weight, age and sex. They cannot see body composition, so they treat 80 kg of muscle and 80 kg of fat identically — even though muscle is metabolically far more expensive to maintain. Katch–McArdle sidesteps the problem by using lean mass alone, which makes it the most accurate of the three for lean or very muscular people, provided your body-fat estimate is good.
What the number is for
BMR on its own is not an eating target. It is the floor — the energy your body spends before you have stood up, walked anywhere or lifted anything. Almost nobody should eat at their BMR.
That multiplier covers three separate things: deliberate exercise, everyday movement (fidgeting, walking, stairs — collectively called NEAT), and the energy cost of digesting food, which runs at roughly 10% of intake.
NEAT is the wildly variable one. Between two people of identical size, it can differ by 800 kcal a day, and it drops silently when you diet. That is a large part of why weight loss slows even when the eating has not changed.
Worked example
A 30-year-old man, 178 cm and 80 kg, has a BMR of about 1,768 kcal. With a desk job that is roughly 2,120 kcal a day; training four times a week it is about 2,740. The difference between those two lifestyles is over 600 kcal daily — more than most people cut when dieting.
What raises and lowers BMR
- Lean mass — the largest controllable factor. More muscle means a higher floor.
- Body size — bigger bodies cost more to run, which is why BMR falls as you lose weight.
- Age — resting metabolism declines gradually in adulthood, largely because muscle mass declines.
- Sex — men average higher BMR at the same height and weight, mostly through greater lean mass.
- Thyroid function — hypothyroidism and hyperthyroidism can shift BMR substantially; this is medical territory.
- Prolonged dieting — sustained deficits suppress resting expenditure beyond what the weight loss alone predicts.
Things that barely matter, despite the marketing: green tea, spicy food, eating six small meals instead of three, and almost every supplement sold as a "metabolism booster". Their combined effect is a rounding error next to lean mass and total activity.